Hidden windows bug = Some young person at Microsoft using AI code (As advised by the CEO) and everything breaking because AI can only do that it’s told to do and it barely does that right.
Every single thing in Microsoft systems are only good when you drill down in the settings. Go down far enough into settings and you start seeing windows 95 UI and it’s because modern day Microsoft have no idea how the actual system works so they just put a new nice coat of paint over the old OS. Windows XP was the last operating system that worked.
Windows XP was the last operating system that worked.
If that was true I wouldn’t be using Linux today
There’s been a few fundamentals been improved since XP like desktop/2D rendering (XP used to have tearing on the desktop and only rendered non-tearing frames for 3D with a suitable GPU and driver). But outside of that, I don’t think there’s actually much more added sincethat hasn’t just been small QOL and UX adjustments and UI updates.
I think if vista didn’t go all out on its visual changes, it might’ve been remembered more fondly like 7. Although I think it was vista that got Microsoft to “solve” the rendering issues of XP i stated earlier, it just went a bit hard on them and the hardware at the time could barely run it as intended.
And yet they still don’t see the advantage of QA their products. Usually they don’t crash their entire platform but they constantly make their own products (impressively).
I do not know why always, but always, every 2 days, my laptop says needs a new update, a new update! I think these are not updates, they are bugs uncovered as updates. But well, I do not know at Microsoft so I do not know.
Since Microshit’s code is closed source, I am forced to assume they AI-ed the shit out of their shit, until they start practicing source code transparency.
Satya Nadella admitted last year himself that about 30% of their code is now AI generated. That share has probably only gotten bigger.
30% of what they add or 30% of the total?
It’s almost like if you had free software the big wouldn’t have been hidden and some nerd would have found it already
When I write the software I’m working on I always add my bugs in plain sight - that makes them easier to fix. Hiding it was such a noob play, Microsoft!
The real pro tip is to create a special branch in source control where you commit all your bugs, and keep the production branch bug free
That’s a really good idea. Streamlining both development and debugging. Nice!
If Lemmy wasn’t so fucking rabidly anti-Microsoft and anti-AI, we might have an interesting discussion about this. But out of all the comments here, it’s all hate.
I’m all for skepticism, but jesus christ everything is the fault of AI and everything is AI and it just absolutely ruins it all.
If the cause is as they said, this is just one of those things that happens. They were testing for problems, and testing on weaker hardware is a Good Thing™ because that’s where a lot of problems happen. So this was an unusual bug. And if what they said is true about some of the mitigation - like extending email delivery times to cause fewer failed emails - they put thought into how to mitigate the damage.
But we apparently can’t discuss any of those things. Everyone was just quick to jump on the MICROSOFT EVIL bandwagon and “don’t put all your eggs in one basket” while that is exactly what you do when you choose your email provider, for example, no matter who you choose. Even with self-hosting, you’re putting all your eggs into the basket of what you use to host it.
I don’t want people to worship any particular tech. I personally like Windows… and Linux… and Andoird… and while I don’t care about anything Apple, for those that use those products and like them, enjoy! I generally don’t feel a need to constantly shit on the things I don’t personally like and prefer.
So yet again, with all the delightful things that happen on Lemmy, here’s another topic that can’t be discussed impartially because of the rabid unhealthy obsession most lemmings have on hating these things to the point that it completely ruins any sort of conversation on the topic.
Now I’ve ranted before, and I expect the downvotes, and I don’t fucking care. I’m sure there will be replies about how this upsets me and I suck or whatever, and you can make those replies to make yourself happy, but I will not be engaging with them. My point, other than just venting my frustration, is in the tiny hope that maybe some might re-evaluate and take a fresh look at it and maybe in future we might have more reasonable conversations. Again, I’m not saying nobody should hate Microsoft, but jesus christ people, the over-the-top “they’re completely lying” and blaming AI is just dumb.
Anyway. Whatever.
Microsoft bad
t everything is the fault of AI and everything is AI
maybe if the ai bros would stop fucking everything up we’d let it go. how much damage do you think they should be able to do to society for their silly fetish before people say something? water, power, gpus, ram, storage, everything is more expensive so Nvidia can ship massive GPUs that sit on fucking loading docks waiting for power and water.
have some self respect for fuck’s sake.
Even with self-hosting, you’re putting all your eggs into the basket of what you use to host it.
You are not limited to one server/service when self-hosting and can definitely spread/replicate your eggs
Thank you for saying this. The Lenny Hate Brigade™ is real and just so exhausting. A couple weeks back I seriously almost bailed on Lemmy altogether because of things like this naive, short-sighted, arrogant blanket hate that is exactly as useful to the world as tankies or MAGA and their beliefs. Because it’s every bit as dogmatic a belief structure as a religion. Purely emotional, no room for doubt or self-reflection lest you be castigated.
I’m no fan of Microsoft, but the cause of a global outage is worth rational discussion and thought. Not brain stem to fingers direct messaging.
Edit: Also, how nuts is it that it was newer equipment that led to this outage?
Forgive us, it just feels like Microsoft is much more focused on AI than fixing anything about any of their products. That’s where the whole Micro-slop nickname comes from. On top of that, I don’t think an operating system should be designed to train AI using any of my data. Which happens by default thanks to notepad, OneDrive, and explorer.
Sincerely, I do not think they are putting their attention where users need it. You’re perspective is understandable, and perhaps valid for those still administrating Windows environments. That said, I am tired of how much customization is necessary to even run Windows on a personal machine. First, I have to watch all the ads in the installer, then I have no choice but to login to my Microsoft account(home edition is awful), then I have to run winutil to disable AI because it doesn’t belong anywhere on a gaming pc, then I have to get my AutoHotKey working, then I have to setup GlazeWM, then install Office… You get the point, I read that difficulty in setting it up and customizing it as anti-consumer behavior and so my feelings towards Microsoft are not great right now.
You may call it hate, I call it exhaustion since I am tired of how much effort Windows takes. And the bugs, like the one that has been around since Windows 8 where you can no longer force show your entire system tray, even if you set the Group policy.
“don’t put all your eggs in one basket” while that is exactly what you do when you choose your email provider, for example, no matter who you choose.
What if you choose gmail and proton or gmail and apple?
I haven’t really followed this outage aside from the emails I have gotten from our infrastructure team at work. However I think the frustration arises around the “don’t put all your eggs in one basket” scenario not because that is what everyone has done, but that they continue to do that.
The whole world has had their eggs in a couple of baskets for the last decade or so and this has happened repeatedly. Every single time it happens everyone is shocked and runs around like chickens with their heads cut off, but then they all go back to it like nothing happened.
I am not agreeing or disagreeing with your stance on the blowback to Microslop, but it is hard to feel bad when people warn everyone about potential global outages by entrusting all the world’s infrastructure to 3 companies. Because yet again we have had that exact problem come to fruition after it happened so many times before.
What are you ranting about? I only see one comment mentioning AI and it’s not even a top level comment, nor is it the most upvoted comment in that comment chain.
Maybe the other comments just aren’t loading on /0, but I’m not seeing a lot of what you’re mentioning. From other comments I learned it was a client side bug, that it’d been out for months, and that culminated in the outage due to an overload of the servers. From your comment 🤷♂️
I hate how Lemmy embraces black-and-white thinking when it comes to certain issues. I mean, I sort of get it when it comes to AI - most of our userbase is tech sector-adjacent, where LLMs have rapidly destroyed job safety and satisfaction, so it’s cathartic to see it fail - but it’s reached bogeyman status where every bug or downtime is blamed on AI until and unless overwhelming evidence to the contrary is presented.
I hate LLMs as much as the next person, but we have decades of evidence showing that these companies can screw up just fine without it.
but we have decades of evidence showing that these companies can screw up just fine without it.
People have short (and selective) memory: since it happened before Lemmy it do not exist, the same way as if something happened before google it does not exist.
For example, seen as someone who is on Internet for around 30 years, Lemmy is only a (maybe) better and simpler version of Usenet nothing new to me, but don’t tell people here…
I hate how Lemmy embraces black-and-white thinking when it comes to certain issues.
I hate how selection bias makes some people claim all of lemmy follows a trend.
Saying that a group does something is not the same as saying every member of that group does it. Like, if I said I hate how right-wing Twitter is, I’m not claiming that literally every user is right-wing, just that the general culture of the place leans that way.
I hate how Lemmy embraces black-and-white thinking when it comes to certain issues.
Cars bad. Motorcycles and bicycles good.
I hate how Lemmy embraces black-and-white thinking when it comes to certain issues.
Hate is a strong word. A great many of us federates are neurospicy, either diagnosed or self-identifying. I’m AuDHD myself. Black and white thinking is how many of us think. Nuance and “grey areas” might as well be unicorns and faeries. And no, it can’t be changed.
We tend to either strongly like or strongly dislike things. But our 2-sided-coin mentality is often well informed and logical. Not always, but often.
Examples from personal experience and being part of ND communities:
Capitalism makes no sense, based on everything ever written and spoken about it. It’s a product of a human trait called greed.
NDs are susceptible to greed, yes. But seeing the entire world beating each other to death over it tears many of us apart inside. So you’ll see a lot of negativity towards capitalism in general here.
LLMs may be great for some NDs, especially as communication aids. However, many of us see LLMs as environmental disasters and career killers. LLMs currently consume resources at an insane, unsustainable rate.
Many NDs work in fields where LLMs are taking away their livelihoods (coding, engineering, art, etc.).
Us NDs don’t have many options when it comes to sustainable and functional careers. Taking away our only links to the world is devastating. So rebelling is all that can be done. It’s difficult to see the positives from a technology disrupting many of our lives in such a negative way.
Microsoft negativity (OP)? I mean, it speaks for itself, no? Terrible company with terrible software, that’s entrenched into all aspects of daily life. Makes no sense. This applies to most giant tech companies these days though.
Politics is another heavily disliked topic in ND circles. It’s all a lie and most people just willingly buy in to a system that is actively working against them. Senseless.
Religion is one that is often very polar in ND circles. As irrational as it is, many ND folk I have met are logical as fuck until god comes up.
Just a few reasons to possibly explain why you are experiencing what you are. Hope that makes sense and you don’t see it as a personal attack. Us NDs tend to say what we mean, and mean what we say. But black and white is who we are.
Yeah - I really dislike AI for the most part. And pretty strongly. I do find it useful for some things - general information, especially information I vet elsewhere if it’s important. (How you ask makes a big difference. heh)
So I think that’s one reason it rankles me as much as it does - because I agree with the disaste for AI overall, just that it’s used as the reasn for all the evils in the world. lol.
And I’m amused. I expected to be downvoted to hell, but I guess I was able to explain myself better this time than some times in the past. lol. Damn contrarian internet! hehehe
Nice profile pic, who’s the artist?
That might be a burn if you didn’t read what I wrote, neh?
lol I once said that AI had helped me with some things I was studying in my doctoral program and everyone under the sun came out to tell me about how terrible my bloodline is, how ashamed my grandma should be of me, and how I should just drop out now
Welcome to Usenet 2.0 🤭
So yet again, with all the delightful things that happen on Lemmy, here’s another topic that can’t be discussed impartially
Another? It’s ANY.
Hug boxes are for hugs, not impartial discussions
Windows is shit though, come on
You couldn’t even bother to write that yourself.
Wow. Found the illiterate jackass proud of being ignorant.
o im sorry ill dum it don so u can undrstand
i rite reel wurds for ppl who fkin reed, not dum ppl hoo not gud reeders
This kinda comment is why I left reddit
Thanks for letting everyone know. We’ll put a note in your file
And dealing with people who think that someone who can write a paragraph or two must have used some external tool because they’re stupid enough to think that nobody could write. That is one of the reasons I have no regrets about leaving Reddit. Pardon the transcription here. I’m on my phone and I’m not going to take the time to type this out.
You forgot to add that everything that goes wrong in the world is because capitalism.
extending email delivery times to cause fewer failed emails
- The standard is like 5 days. Did they manage 1?
- ‘mail’ is a mass noun.
Yeah I hate it here
“Whew boy… I’m glad Microsoft was taken down by a ‘hidden bug’, rather than one of those run-of-mill bugs I’m sure they’ve got.” /s
Those are features. Thank you for helping this budding start-up with software test validation and paying for the privilege.
To save the curious among you some scrolling:
the change ran globally for more than three months without visible problems. […] Microsoft says neither the defect nor that fix applies to general Windows deployments, separating this incident from a Windows desktop issue.
Inside an internal Windows process, competing tasks were waiting for access to shared resources, a problem called lock contention. Under certain traffic conditions, this exhausted processor and memory capacity.
Connection requests piled up until servers stopped responding. Microsoft’s tests missed the issue because they focused on weaker machines, while the fault became worse on newer hardware with more cores.
Deadlock and livelock are common software failure modes that engineers know to prepare for in professional environments. There are mitigations, like timers that lead to interrupt request, prioritization, etc.
We shouldn’t believe anything they say. Two aviation outages, a worldwide outage on the most integrated software in the world, and then banks go down in a separate incident, all in three days and starting the week these fascists lose in the midterms?
Wake the fuck up people. When Russell Vought said there wouldn’t be bloodshed unless dems accepted a takeover peacefully, he was saying they will kill for their agenda. Believe them when they tell you who they are.
The “micro” in Microsoft is for their competency level.
Always bear in mind that Microsoft means small and limp.
It seemed to be for their management, for a while.
And for the type of females Bill Gates is attracted to, just like his late good friend Epstein
Just FYI, try using “women” instead of “females” as the former is more inclusive. The latter is used more by people that are bigots and fascists.
I’m sorry since when did children become women?
Girls in that case.
Downvotes for calling out Bill Gates for being caught up in the Epstein files? Lots of Destiny-style liberalism finding its way onto .world these days I see
Its preliminary incident report, dated November 15
I want to read this, but I only see links to other articles on this site, and a couple of useless forum threads.
Microsoft released it as a post to Insider Admins only. I did find this repost on Twitter tho:
Interesting. A client side bug causes server-level overload but only after unrelated changes gradually make the problem worse. Rerouting traffic to healthy servers overloads those too and spreads the outage. The client code surely “worked on my computer” lol
Probably.
Joking aside, the problem with testing is that you normally cannot have a complete copy of the production env to test against, with all the possible cases.
You may have a test env that do not trigger certain corner case scenario which can be dependent on something completely out of the domain, like in this case.If they learned something, they would add some way of testing even this kind of scenario in the future.
Where did they say it was a client side bug?
I guess I misunderstood it.
Inside an internal Windows process, competing tasks were waiting for access to shared resources, a problem called lock contention. Under certain traffic conditions, this exhausted processor and memory capacity.
I read this as the behavior that precipitated the issue on the gateway was caused by how Windows sent traffic to exchange servers. So by Windows they mean whatever is running on the gateway?
It says multiple times that the issue was with Microsoft’s internal cloud server software, not Windows.
The defect came from a fix prepared specifically for Microsoft 365 networking gateway servers.
The failure was within Microsoft’s cloud infrastructure, not customer Windows systems
Yeah exactly, I don’t understand how the original comment is still getting upvotes.
Since your comment it gained (+36, -11). People don’t read, I guess.
Why do I find myself doubting this lol
Nobody is willing/allowed to admit the truth: “We used AI and it blew up in our face instantly” goes for the flights grounding, Iranian school, etc
It’s a good question. Did you perhaps want it to be some other explanation, and so now that you got an explanation you didn’t want you prefer to doubt it?
It’s definitely this haha
According to this they are funneling all traffic through a single “gateway”. What the fuck?
No, it definately says “gateway servers” at least once.
The “Moving from the secondary gateway to the primary gateway” probably means “from the secondary gateway deployment to the primary gateway deployment”.
They might have been A/B or blue/green deploying a new gateway system. Or perhaps the old gateway system was on outdated hardware and were transitioning to new gateway hardware (which lines up with “this impacted more powerful hosts more” kinda thing they say).Even if it’s a single virtual node per region, it would be fully load balanced across probably thousands of servers per region.
deleted by creator


















